Playwright and actor Andrew Moodie has started the Share the Stage campaign to get the Shaw Festival to embrace colour-blind casting. The idea came to him after a rejection by the Festival:
I had submitted a play to the Festival for consideration and it had been turned down. This didn’t upset me. If you’re a playwright in this country you’re used to rejection letters. What concerned me was the reason. It was made clear to me that they play would never get produced at Shaw because the cast had too many people of colour.
The person who told me this information made it clear that they were disgusted with the policy of the theatre, but she would rather be honest with me, and allow me to find a theatre that would be sincerely interested in working with me. And I did. I was able to get the support I needed to get the play produced. But, what was said to me, haunts me. Does the Festival actually have a policy to exclude people based on race? I decided to pay attention to the amount of diversity on the stage, and season after season I have to say that my concerns have not been put to rest.
If you have read any of his work, you would know that George Bernard Shaw was a staunch critic of discrimination. Canada has become a wonderful multi-ethnic cultural mosaic. Time and time again, this has been considered one of this nations strengths, that so many people, from so many different cultures share the same country in peace and prosperity. I honestly believe that if Shaw were alive today, he, too, would embrace our diversity as a strength and not a weakness. And we are very fortunate to have many, MANY, performers from diverse ethnic backgrounds, who are more than capable of performing lead roles in any of Shaw’s greatest works.
The Globe‘s theatre critic J. Kelly Nestruck weighs in on the issue with his own observations of the festival’s casting:
Back in May, near the end of the opening week at the Shaw Festival, I was suddenly struck by how overwhelmingly white the festival’s acting company is.
Ironically enough, this hit me while I was at the festival’s production of Lillian Hellman’s The Little Foxes, which is set in the deep South in the year 1900 and deals explicitly with issues of race and racism. Watching actors Lisa Codrington and Richard Stewart as the servants Addie and Cal, I realised the only other actor of colour I had seen all week (outside of the musical) had been playing a maid.
What a time warp. I thought: How would this make me feel if I was a young, non-white actor coming to the Shaw Festival for the first time? Pretty alienated, I imagine.
And so, in my review of The Little Foxes, I noted (though only parenthetically) that: “For better or for worse, colour-blind casting has yet to reach Niagara-on-the-Lake, Ont.”
Fair comment I thought, but it provoked a defensive email from the Shaw’s artistic director, Jackie Maxwell, in response. She insisted that I had come up with a “very inaccurate head count” (because I ignored the musical, Wonderful Town) and concluded: “I would be happy to talk further to you about this – first waiting, of course, until you have come up with some accurate figures… and maybe ’til you have seen a few more shows too – that might help.”
Well, I’ve seen the rest of the 2008 season now and – what can I say – I’m still not about to nominate the festival for any diversity awards. The contrast with Canada’s other big repertory company is striking. Over at the Stratford Festival, there are actors of colour playing Juliet, Helen of Troy, Christopher Sly, Cleopatra (in a play by Bernard Shaw, no less) and rebellious Fuente Ovejunians, to name just a few. There isn’t a big fuss made about it, either. Maybe it’s because Shakespeare’s characters were originally all played by male actors, but non-traditional casting is just the way Stratford roles. (Apologies.)
Shaw artistic director Jackie Maxwell does seem interested in addressing the situation.